I'm looking into a 357 SA/DA Revolver with 6" barrel and am currently considering these two discontinued models based on their reputation and some experience. What matters to me is that they're tight, slick, reliable, and sturdy. I'm not looking for something to hot load, so it doesn't have to be overbuilt - just built right. One thing that matters to me is a low barrel axis for minimum muzzle jump. Haven't exactly been able to measure these yet. So what would you choose? Please, if you choose "other", only do so if you believe that your choice is actually superior to either of these two for some reason besides price.