G3, Keep in mind, some of the "chunky" guns you mention are double stack, albeit neutered 10 round capacity political victims.
IMOHO the 1911 has allways had good carry characteristics. The biggest debate seems to be the condition issues. Other wise, it's flat, 6~8 rounds are enough realistically, there are tons of configurations, everyone has parts and the knowledge to work on them, you have a choice of 9,40,or45.
jarcp is correct, don't let the slide issue influence your decision making process. The odds of someone taking your gun from you and beating you with it are greater. If the encounter is that close, you better have good weapons retention skills any way.
Field stripping a 1911 cumbersome and time consuming? I think not. I can have my slide off in under a second. Spring, bushing & barrel in another 20~30 seconds. I do have to hold my tongue just right on re-assembly to get the slide release pin through the barrel link and frame. No biggie.
Whatever you get you have to be comfortable with and practice alot.
IMOHO the 1911 has allways had good carry characteristics. The biggest debate seems to be the condition issues. Other wise, it's flat, 6~8 rounds are enough realistically, there are tons of configurations, everyone has parts and the knowledge to work on them, you have a choice of 9,40,or45.
jarcp is correct, don't let the slide issue influence your decision making process. The odds of someone taking your gun from you and beating you with it are greater. If the encounter is that close, you better have good weapons retention skills any way.
Field stripping a 1911 cumbersome and time consuming? I think not. I can have my slide off in under a second. Spring, bushing & barrel in another 20~30 seconds. I do have to hold my tongue just right on re-assembly to get the slide release pin through the barrel link and frame. No biggie.
Whatever you get you have to be comfortable with and practice alot.