Pentagon destroys thousands of copies of Army officer's memoir

Discussion in 'Political/Religious Topics' started by grizcty, Sep 26, 2010.

  1. grizcty

    grizcty God, Guns, Glory Forum Contributor

    Am I the only one, who thinks this sounds fishy?

    Pentagon destroys thousands of copies of Army officer's memoir

    By Chris Lawrence and Padma Rama, CNN


    • The Department of Defense says the memoir contained state secrets
    • The book's author calls the destruction "ludicrous"
    • A second printing of the book incorporates redactions requested by the Pentagon

    Washington (CNN) -- The Department of Defense recently purchased and destroyed thousands of copies of an Army Reserve officer's memoir in an effort to safeguard state secrets, a spokeswoman said Saturday.
    "DoD decided to purchase copies of the first printing because they contained information which could cause damage to national security," Pentagon spokeswoman Lt. Col. April Cunningham said.
    In a statement to CNN, Cunningham said defense officials observed the September 20 destruction of about 9,500 copies of Army Reserve Lt. Col. Anthony Shaffer's new memoir "Operation Dark Heart."
    Shaffer says he was notified Friday about the Pentagon's purchase.
    "The whole premise smacks of retaliation," Shaffer told CNN on Saturday. "Someone buying 10,000 books to suppress a story in this digital age is ludicrous."
    Shaffer's publisher, St. Martin's Press, released a second printing of the book that it said had incorporated some changes the government had sought "while redacting other text he (Shaffer) was told was classified."
    From single words and names to entire paragraphs, blacked out lines appear throughout the book's 299 pages.
    CNN obtained a memo from the Defense Intelligence Agency dated August 6 in which Lt. Gen. Ronald Burgess claims the DIA tried for nearly two months to get a copy of the manuscript. Burgess said the DIA's investigation "identified significant classified information, the release of which I have determined could reasonably be expected to cause serious damage to national security."
    Burgess said the manuscript contained secret activities of the U.S. Special Operations Command, CIA and National Security Agency.
    Shaffer's lawyer, Mark Zaid, said earlier this month that the book was reviewed by Shaffer's military superiors prior to publication.
    "There was a green light from the Army Reserve Command," Zaid told CNN.
    But intelligence agencies apparently raised objections when they received copies of the book.
    The Pentagon contacted St. Martin's Press in early August to convey its concerns over the release of the book. According to the publisher, at that time the first printings were just about to be shipped from its warehouse. Shaffer said he and the publisher worked hard "to make sure nothing in the book would be detrimental to national security."
    "When you look at what they took out (in the 2nd edition), it's lunacy," Shaffer said.
    The Pentagon says Shaffer should have sought wider clearance for the memoir.
    "He did clear it with Army Reserve but not with the larger Army and with Department of Defense," Department of Defense spokesman Col. David Lapan said earlier this month. "So he did not meet the requirements under Department of Defense regulations for security review."
    One of the book's first lines reads, "Here I was in Afghanistan (redaction) My job: to run the Defense Intelligence Agency's operations out of (redaction) the hub for U.S. operations in country."
    In chapter 15, titled "Tipping Point," 21 lines within the first two pages are blacked out.
    In the memoir, Shaffer recalls his time in Afghanistan leading a black-ops team during the Bush administration. The Bronze Star medal recipient told CNN he believes the Bush administraton's biggest mistake during that time was misunderstanding the culture there.
    Defense officials said they are in the process of reimbursing the publisher for the cost of the first printing and have not purchased copies of the redacted version.
    At least one seller on the online auction site eBay claiming to have a first-edition printing is selling it for an asking price of nearly $2,000. The listed retail price for the second printing is $25.99.

    Find this article at:
    Pentagon destroys thousands of copies of Army officer's memoir -
  2. Whenever our government wants to hide their secrets they claim national security. The wiki leaks case was a prime example. The government stated that the documents could be harmful to our troops in theatre. This is absurd. They want to hide illegal covert missions from public view. This has been going on since the dawn of time. That is what is in the book that the government has purchased, THE TRUTH! It is supposed to be a government for the PEOPLE by the PEOPLE, however, that is not the case. The people want to know the truth not lies.

  3. TACAV

    TACAV G&G Evangelist Forum Contributor


    Well the flip side of that coin is that pretty much every government from the beginning of time has engaged and conducted "illegal black ops missions" here and there and forever will. Our enemies do it, and we do it.

    We and everyone else will continue to do it because in the bigger picture well to put it bluntly, there is no other way to get certain things done or to obtain certain information.

    This ranges everything from the US spying on our enemies, extracting and securing foreign defectors to even setting up/ funding/planning, or assisting in the assassination of other people.

    In a lot of cases as And as dastardly as that sounds, its sort of a necessary evil.

    Although in this book case it does seem silly in that apparently no one cared when this book was first being written and produced until someone did a second take on it and was like. Oh crap how did we miss this?

    SUBMOA G&G Evangelist

    This Anthony Shaffer was invollved with operation "able danger" which was a computer data mining operation that was trying to identify terrorists on us soil. He went public after 9-11 and said that the inteligence group had identified mohamed ata and others prior to 9-11 but nothing was done.there was a 9-11 hearing which finding said in Condolesa Rice's words " there was no smoking gun"And thats what the comission eventually said. My guess is that this action being taken now is in retalliation to him going public.
  5. kansascoyote

    kansascoyote G&G Newbie

    A court marshel is in order .
  6. Rave

    Rave G&G Evangelist

    "And the band played on.":eek:mfg: